
I remember watching Superbad in the theater and laughing, but not really loving it. But because I love Apatow special features (the Knocked Up 2 disc set is probably my favorite DVD of all time), I bought the DVD and gave it another spin. The jokes were spoiled, so I didn’t laugh much, and realized that I intensely didn’t like it. I got the idea they were going for, a modern day Porky’s, the kind of raunchy R-rated high school “let’s get laid” comedy that hasn’t been done well since probably American Pie. But I just found it listless and kind of pointless, nothing about it stuck out to me. So for a while, it sat on my shelf between the other Apatow movies I’ve watched and rewatched countless times gathering dust. And then a few months ago, I decided to pull it out again, for old time’s sake. And weirdly, I found that I actually liked it. Even weirder, I REALLY liked it.

I began thinking back on all the movies that I didn’t like at first, and grew to enjoy later. Office Space is probably the definitive example of this phenomenon in my movie viewing history. When I first saw Mike Judge’s modern classic, I didn’t get it. Maybe it’s because I was young and had never worked in an office (something that, as a business student, I would come to learn only too well later in life), but something about the movie was too..on the nose. The jokes were well written and well delivered, but nothing about them made me laugh aloud in the way that a simpler comedy would. Nothing about it was special to me, and so I just chalked it up to a movie that I just assumed wasn’t my cup of tea.
Office Space only became great when I spoke about it with friends over the next nine years of my life, as moments would occur and I’d catch a glimpse from my friend on a joke we could both remember from the movie. It started with the endless quoting, referencing, and late night discussions about the how we wish “Damn It Feels Good to be a Gangsta” could be the soundtrack to every shining moment in our lives, and then culminated in college dorm movie marathons where Office Space became something easy to throw on, because everyone could laugh at it, while ignoring it. The movie was more about the community it created, rather than the movie itself, and to this day when I watch Office Space, I don’t laugh at the movie, I laugh with it and remember all the moments it’s created in my mind.

In a lot of ways, that’s Judge’s charm. While there may be plenty of people who love his movies on first viewing, I find myself outside of that circle, as the same phenomenon happened with his newest movie Idiocracy. I’m not one of the people who walked out of this movie and pointed at our current society, saying it was close to Idiocracy’s dumbed down view of the future, but the genius of this movie is the way it puts these time bombs inside of your mind, on paper they may not be utterly hilarious, but shared with friends, they become classic moments. It’s something that Judge seems to understand, the difference between relatability (i.e. say, an Apatow movie) and the viral aspect of humor. You could arguably say that Beavis and Butthead started this age of viral humor, something that on paper, looks completely vapid, but when engaged with and relayed to others, it becomes a proactive experience. And because you own a little bit of it, it becomes personal, it’s all our inside joke, so we laugh a bit harder.

To turn away from straight up comedies, I had a similar experience with The Big Lebowski, and really most Coen Bros. movies in general. On paper, there’s no reason that Lebowski works, even in viewing the movie it’s kind of a wandering fever dream of a movie that isn’t grounded in reality, but not fully in the abstract. But the massive cult following that it’s built up is anchored in a similar quotable, viral, inside joke aspect, that this movie is “ours,” and we love it because it speaks to us. A lot of Coen movies find this kind of following, if you find someone who’s a Miller’s Crossing fan, chances are he’s not a passive MC fan, he thinks it’s one of the greatest movies ever made (like me). But Lebowski takes that shared experience to a new ground…it’s not about the laughs, and it’s not about the weed, and it’s not about the quotes, it’s about the religion and culture that the movie creates.

Superbad is strange, b/c it’s not so much about a religion or culture, and it’s not about quotes. The one thing that’s interesting about Apatow movies is their lack of quotability. Sure, there are funny lines, but rarely does the writing push the dialogue to the front in the way that other humor movies do. Quick, think of your favorite Apatow movie quote. It’s probably something embedded within regular speaking between characters, or an improvised throwaway line that just stuck in your head. But upon repeated viewings, when you ignore the jokes (or rather, the jokes have no effect on you), you start to see that it’s just an enjoyable world to be in, regardless of how aimless it might be. Between 40 Year Old Virgin, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, and Knocked Up, movies that contain jokes within the structure of an emotional narrative, Superbad is the break from all that, it’s floating around in the pool after swimming laps, and though I can’t explain it, there is something enjoyable about it in a way that doesn’t require any kind of a shared experience. In the way that Office Space and Idiocracy get better with community, I’ve found Superbad to get better when viewed in isolation, and I’ve come to the conclusion that it’s because the jokes are simply not meant to be talked about. It’s a weirdly earnest movie, that doesn’t try to hide the fact that it loves the brand of humor that it does, even though at times, it’s dripping with self deprecation, or even as far as self loathing. And that’s appealing, in a weird, masochistic way, and better viewed when you’re by yourself.
I don’t mean to overinflate the importance of raunchy comedies. It is what it is. But there’s something more going on with simple, stupid movies, and I don’t mean that the stories themselves are more complex than we believe them to be. They’re communal experiences, and when done right, they create the community, rather than pull in the already existing age demographic that likes to laugh at fart jokes. And sometimes, movies like that deserve a second or third look before you toss it in the loss column.